Group+A+3-C-1+Workspace

=Home > Learning Activity 3-C-1: Immigration Cartoons > Group A 3-C-1 Workspace=


 * Venn Diagram**

Resources - Very useful group of sources to support your conclusions and findings. Chris
[]

[]

[]

[]

[]

Work Area- Good documentation by date of event and activity for the project. Chris
6/18: I just deleted the other Venn Diagram!

6/18: Ok. Looks good. I found information to substantiate some of our simiarities and diffierences and posted them in the resources.

6/18: I made a couple of slight revisions to the Venn, and I uploaded the revision.

6/17: Looks really good so far. I like what you have worked on I just got back from my parents, where my computer access was limited. I added the Venn Diagram and im adding a few points to what you made so far! Overall, looks like you really researche the two cartoons well.!

6/15: We are comparing two Puck cartoons. Cartoon #1 is entitled "Welcome to All," and Cartoon #2 is called "As to Japanese Exclusion."

Similarities -Anti-immigrant (although "Welcome to All" is less negative than "Japanese Exclusion") -Reflected the countries image of immigration policies -Focuses on immigrants from many different countries -Uses negative stereotypes of different nationalities -All of the immigrants pictured are very poor and destitute

Differences "Welcome to All" "As to Japanese Exclusion" -Published in 1880 -Published in 1913 -Implies that America is too generous to immigrants -Implies that no one from Japan should be allowed to immigrate into the United States -"Welcome All" looked like the immagrants were boarding Noah's Arch -Implies that a primary reason for immigration is the "free lunch" -Has various "undesirable" nationalities all dressed in Japanese kimonos. -"Welcome All" has Uncle Sam, a symbol our nation welcoming the immigrants. "As to Japnese Exclusion" has someone looking like a police officer stopping them. immigrants get when they arrive. -Implies that immigrants from many East European nations should be subject to the same -Also shows possibly legitimate reasons immigrants claim to want to immigration restrictions as Japanese. come to America. -Implies that immigrants from Eastern Europe are violent revolutionaries who are carrying bombs, knives, and guns "Welcome to All" the immigrants are pictured boarding the boat from the west. "As to Japanese Exclusion" pictures them boarding from the east. In the 1880 cartoon the storm clouds say "war" and "distress." In "Welcome to All" Uncle Sam is holding his arms open to receive the immigrants. In "Japanese Exclusion" the boat captain has his hands as if to say, "Stop!"

Thanks for working together in a collborative format. You have documented by date your interaction with one another. The Venn Diagram clearly outlines the similarites and differences of the two sources. Thanks for using the workspace provided on this Wiki as a way to collborate and work with one anohter to complete this assignment. Chris