Group+C+3-C-1+Workspace

=Home > Learning Activity 3-C-1: Immigration Cartoons > Group C 3-C-1 Workspace=

Resources
[] [|http://books.google.com/books?id=x8OggvKjZSgC&pg=PA191&lpg=PA191&dq=where+both+platforms+agree&source=bl&ots=dogum5NK10&sig=Cj6x4mdNyIjeRbSdJddtrY_jYv8&hl=en&ei=LNgcTLCUCYWdlgeXyoGyDg&sa=X&oi=book_result&ct=result&resnum=1&ved=0CBUQ6AEwAA#v=onepage&q=where%20both%20platforms%20agree&f=false]

Work Area
6/19 Jessica, I was confused about this project, but I think we were supposed to discuss similarities and differences first, then select one person to create the Venn. Let me know...

__"Welcome to All"__ -Upper right hand corner clouds look like angry monsters and have the words "war" and "distress" written. (RP) -One of the signs implies that everything in the U.S. will be free (lunch, education, land, etc... (RP) -The sign portrays a key freedom from the founding fathers - democracy is based freedoms such as self-determination, speech, religion, life, liberty, & property. The cartoonists may be criticizing the free lunch as too extreme though. (JF) - Clouds indicated push factors enticing Europeans to head to America (JF)

__Where Both Play Forms Agree"__ -Shows anti-Chinese immigration. (RP) -Portrays Chinese as monsters who were taking jobs away from Americans (RP) -Both Democrats and Republicans agreed Naturalization Act prohibiting Chinese immigrants form entering U.S. (RP)

__Both:__ -Both are anti-immigrants. (RP) Is the first one really anti-immigrant? On the site the oracle site you have above, it says Uncle Sam is warmly welcoming the immigrants & the restrictive policies don't start until 13 years later. (JF) -In both, immigrants are viewed negatively, as taking away from Americans. (RP) -Both show the Social Darwinist theory of the higher order of being. (JF)

Hi Rosie, I wasn't sure about this either. I re-read the assignment & the e-mails multiple times & I thought that we were supposed to use the diagram as our discussiong format & just re-save it each time we made changes. J

If that is the case, I can not figure out how to do it. That is what I did initially, but then saw that we were supposed to go back and forth on the work area, then designate one person to create the final diagram. "5. Based on your discussion, elect one team member to fill out the Venn Diagram worksheet." (RP)

That's fine, if you want me to put everything onto the diagram, I'll just wait until I hear back from you. J

Jessica-I added my ideas to yours. Let me know if it looks ok. (RP)

Just added a few last thoughts. I think we've got everything covered! Thanks! J

Jessica and Rosie, your Wiki workspace shows an ongoing method of collaboration, which led to the final preparation of a well developed venn diagram. Your resources provided insight into the images so that you could make connections to the political and social elements of the resources. Well done! Good documentation of collaboration in an organized and clear format. Thanks for your efforts. Chris